Appeal Court Nullifies N20bn Damages Awarded Against DSS, Judgment of High Court in Favour of Igboho

The N20 billion exemplary and aggravated damages awarded by the Oyo State High Court in favour of Yoruba secessionist agitator, Chief Sunday Adeyemo, popularly called Sunday Igboho, against the Department of State Security (DSS), for invading his home, has been nullified by the Ibadan division of the Court of Appeal, which also reversed the judgment of the lower court that declared the attack as illegal.

Justice Muslim Hassan, not only described the judgment as outrageous but also said the lower court lacked jurisdiction on the matter and should not have awarded damages based on his personal parameters.

The Attorney-General of the Federation and Minister of Justice, Abubakar Malami, appealed the judgment of Justice Ladiran Akintola, which favoured Adeyemo, who demanded N500 billion damages in his fundamental rights enforcement suit filed against the AGF and the DSS, after the invasion of the house, situated in Ibadan, Oyo state, was invaded on July 1, last year.

Justice Ladiran Akintola of the Oyo State High Court had in September 2021, declared the action, which left two occupants of the house dead and twelve others arrested, as an arbitrary aggression and against Adeyemo, ordering the DSS to pay N20 billion to the plaintiff as exemplary and aggravated damages.

According to him, the style and procedures adopted by the DSS, during the incident, were unprofessional and the applicant had demonstrated to the court that his fundamental right to personal liberty, right to life and blocking of his account amounted to a violation of his fundamental rights.

He awarded N20 billion as exemplary and aggravated damage in favour of the applicant and N2 million for instituting the case.

Adeyemo, through his lawyer, Yomi Alliyu, was seeking the enforcement of his fundamental human rights, pursuant to Sections 33-46 of the 1999 Constitution as amended and relevant articles of the African Charter on Human and Peoples Rights.

He wanted an order to the respondents to jointly pay him the sum ₦500 million as special damages and another ₦500 billion as exemplary and aggravated damages, for beaching his fundamental rights as well as a public apology by the Federal Government in two national dailies and the return of all items seized from the house.

However, counsel to the AGF, Abdullah Abubakar, who countered the claim, said there was no evidence before the court that the blood seen in the video clip tendered by Adeyemos lawyer belonged to a human being.

He also asked the court to disregard exhibits and dismiss the entire suit, as there was nothing in the video clip that showed that the house that was invaded belonged to Adeyemo or linked the AGF with the invasion.

Counsel to the DSS, T. A. Nurudeen, further submitted that there must be proof from a hematologist to show that the blood seen in the video belonged to a human being.

He tendered a video clip, which was admitted by the court, showing Adeyemo allegedly threatening to create an Oduduwa Republic and also asking Yorubas to protect themselves with charms and guns.

Adeyemo was arrested in July 2021, in the Benin Republic, when he was trying to flee Nigeria for Germany.

He was tried and released on March 7, on health grounds, after eight months in prison, but is still in the country on the orders of the Beninoise government.

 

Comments (0)
Add Comment