The Court of Appeal, sitting in Abuja, has set aside the decision of the Osun State Election Petition Tribunal, voiding the election of Senator Ademola Adeleke, as the governor of the state.
It upheld the election of Adeleke, in a unanimous decision by a three-man panel, led by Justice Mohammed Shuaibu and quashed the judgment of the tribunal, which had declared former governor Oyetola, of the All Progressives Congress (APC), as the winner.
The Election Petition Tribunal had nullified Adeleke’s declaration by INEC as the winner of the state’s governorship election, on the grounds that Adeleke did not score a majority of lawful votes in the governorship polls.
However, in a unanimous decision on Friday, a three-man panel led by Justice Mohammed Shuaibu, the Court of Appeal quashed the tribunal’s judgment and declared Adeleke, of the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP), as the rightful governor of the state.
The court revoked the tribunal’s order, which directed that a Certificate of Return be withdrawn from Adeleke and issued to Oyetola.
It said it was wrong for the tribunal to have said that there was over-voting.
The tribunal had on January 27, sacked Adeleke as governor, on the grounds of over-voting in 744 polling units
He was said to have won 17 out of the 30 Local Government Areas in the state.
The tribunal, led by Terste Kume, in a split decision of two-to-one, directed INEC to withdraw the certificate of return issued to Adeleke and his deputy, Kola Adewusi, both of whom had been sworn in.
It directed that the certificate should instead be issued to Oyetola.
The judge had ruled that the governorship election was not held in compliance with Nigeria’s Electoral Act and also characterised by over-voting.
Tertsea said that the excess votes were deducted following which Oyetola won the election.
According to him, having deducted the over-voting figure, Oyetola scored 314,921, while Ademola polled 290,266 votes.
Dissatisfied with the judgment, Adeleke, the PDP and Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) approached the Court of Appeal asking for the setting aside of the tribunal’s judgment.
The appellants had asked the court to set aside the judgment because the tribunal occasioned a miscarriage of justice and misdirected itself in arriving at its conclusion that there was over-voting during the election.
They said the judgment should be declared a nullity, as a member of the tribunal, Chief Magistrate Basiru Rabi, who signed it did not contribute to the findings of the tribunal as required by law.
To them, for Rabi to make pronouncements with regards to the lead judgment other than appending her signature, rendered the entire judgment nullity.
Adeleke in the 31 grounds of appeal prayed the court for “an order setting aside the whole decision of the tribunal.”
The governor equally sought, “an order striking out the petition for want of competence and jurisdiction or in the alternative, an order dismissing the petition on the merit.
“The tribunal, in its judgment, erred in law and displayed bias against the appellant when it made reference to the appellant’s dance at his inauguration as governor of Osun state which was never an issue before the lower tribunal.
“By referring to the appellant’s personal eccentricity for dancing, the lower tribunal derided and mocked him in a manner suggesting that it was biased against him.
“The appearance of bias manifests in the reference to the Appellant’s proclivity for dancing and particularly the Buga song, has rendered the decision of the lower Tribunal a nullity,” the appellant said.
June, while delivering the judgment, had stated, “the second respondent cannot ‘go lo lo lo lo’ and ‘buga won’ as the duly elected governor of Osun state.”