The Presidential Election Petition Tribunal (PEPT) Court, on Wednesday, affirmed the declaration of President Ahmed Bola Tinubu as the winner of the February 25 Presidential election by the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC).
The five-member panel, led by Justice Haruna Tsammani, in a unanimous judgment, after over 12 hours of sitting, dismissed petitions filed by the Allied Peoples Movement (APM) and its Candidate, Princess ChiChi Ojei; Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) and its Candidate, Alhaji Atiku Abubakar and Labour Party (LP) and its Candidate, Peter Obi.
Dismissing the petition of the Allied People’s Movement (APM) on the eligibility of President Bola Tinubu and Vice President Kashim Shettima to contest the election, the tribunal’s Chairman, Justice Haruna Tsammani, who read the judgment, said the tribunal lacks the jurisdiction to hear or determine an issue bordering on qualification or non-qualification of a candidate.
APM had submitted that Shettima was still a senatorial candidate as of 14th July when he was nominated as the vice presidential candidate.
However, the court said the allegation of double nomination made against Shettima has no substance, having been settled by the Supreme Court. He said no one has the right to litigate on it again.
PEPT said the issue of qualification or non-qualification is a pre-election matter that should have been ventilated at the federal high court within 14 days after the conduct of a primary election.
It said APM lacks the locus standi to challenge the qualification of a candidate in another political party.
It said only an aspirant who took part in a primary election can challenge the outcome of such an election.
It cited the judgment of the Supreme Court of 26th May, this year, in which it dismissed an appeal filed by PDP.
APM submitted that Shettima was still a senatorial candidate as of 14th July when he was nominated as the vice presidential candidate.
Tsammani held that there is evidence before the tribunal to prove that Shettima sent a letter to the Independent National Electoral on 6th July, resigning his position as Borno Central senatorial candidate, adding that his nomination as vice presidential candidate cannot be regarded as a double nomination.
Also dismissing the petition filed by the LP and Obi, the court said although the party and its candidate, claimed to have scored the majority of lawful votes cast, they failed to state the number of lawful votes scored by Obi to prove that it scored majority of lawful votes cast in February 28 poll.
Reading the judgment Justice Abba Mohammed said the petitioners only made “generic accusations of irregularities in the election, but failed to specify the anomaly, the places where it occurred and those affected.
“They failed to state the number of votes affected and the number of people disenfranchised.
“They also failed to prove that their votes were suppressed by failing to specify the number of votes suppressed.
“The determination of election is about figures,” the court said.
The court threw out the claim that Tinubu was indicted over an alleged drug indictment in the United States and thus not eligible to contest the election.
It said the petitioner failed to prove that the respondent was convicted of money laundering in the US, adding no record of criminal arrest or conviction.
Tinubu, it added, was not arraigned, did not take plea and there was no sentence of imprisonment imposed on him.
On the prayer that Tinubu should be disqualified from being president because didn’t win 25 percent of the votes cast in the FCT, the court said that the FCT does not enjoy a special status and therefore equal to every other state in Nigeria, and therefore, the claim was irrelevant.
On the claim they INEC did not comply with the Electoral Act 2022, which stipulates electronic transmission of election results, the court said the only technological device that was mandatory to use for the election is the Bimodal Voter Accreditation System (BVAS).
It said there is nothing in the regulation to show that the BVAS must electronically transmit polling units results, adding that the commission’s Results Viewing Portal (IReV) is not a collation system.
“There is no provision for the electronic transmission of election results in the Electoral Act 2022. It is at best optional.”
On the petition of Atiku, the court frowned at what it said was the introduction of several facts and allegations in unlawful ways that caught the respondents unaware.
According to it, the tactic employed was unfair and made him clever by half.
Justice Stephen Jonah Adah, who read the decision of the PEPT, noted that the offending new facts said to have been wrongfully introduced were the allegations of criminal conviction, certificate forgery, dual citizenship of Guinea made against Tinubu outside the mode of filing petition.
The court then expunged several documents tendered by Atiku in his petition, ruling that the exhibits were made during the pendency of the petition.
Also, the evidence of several key witnesses of Atiku were expunged from the Court record having been made in manners not known to law.
The court said that the wrongful mode adopted by the petitioner in the construction of the petition made several paragraphs of the petition liable for striking out for want of merit.
Several other exhibits, including witnesses’ statements tendered to establish allegations of irregularities, malpractices against the respondent were rejected and dis-countenanced.
It ruled that several parts of Atiku’s petition have no legs upon which they can stand and survive, and so were not competent.
Atiku was told that he failed and neglected to name places where ballot boxes were snatched, the ways and manners the BVAS machine were manipulated and names of polling boots, where alleged malpractices took place.
On the allegations against Kogi State Governor, Yahaya Bello and the Chairman of Olamaboro Local Government of Kogi, Friday Adejoh, the court said Atiku did not join them as respondents in the petition, ruling that the failure to prove electoral fraud against them was fatal to the petition, as because the governor was denied opportunity to defend himself as required by law.
The allegations of overvoting all over the country by the petitioner, the court added, run foul of the law, because the specific places where the alleged overvoting took place were not mentioned.
Several other exhibits, including witnesses’ statements tendered to establish allegations of irregularities, malpractices against the respondent were rejected and dis-countenanced.
It ruled that several parts of Atiku’s petition have no legs upon which they can stand and survive, and so were not competent.
Atiku was told that he failed and neglected to name places where ballot boxes were snatched, the ways and manners the BVAS machine were manipulated and names of polling boots, where alleged malpractices took place.
INEC had said Tinubu scored a total of 8,794,726 votes to emerge victorious.
He was followed by Atiku with 6,984,520 votes, and Obi, with 6,101,533 votes.
Tinubu’s main challengers, Ojei, Obi and Abubakar were not in court.
The president is presently in India to attend the G-20 Summit.
The Vice President, Kashim Shettima, Chairman of the APC, Abdullahi Ganduje, Chief of Staff to the President, Femi Gbajabiamila, National Security Adviser, Nuhu Ribadu, Governors Abdullahi Sule (Nasarawa) and Bala Mohammed (Bauchi), Yahaya Bello (Kogi), Hope Uzodinma (Imo), Mai Mala Buni (Yobe) and Banji Oyetola (Ekiti), were present in court.
Also in court were the Acting National Chairman of PDP, Umar Damagum, National Chairman of LP, Julius Abure, National Secretary of APC, Ajibola Basiru, former Deputy Senate President, Ovie Omo-Agege, Minister for Aviation, Festus Keyamo (SAN), Hon. James Falake, Director General of the Obi/Datti Campaign Organisation, Akin Osuntokun and supporter of Obi, Aisha Yesufu.
Nollywood stars at the court were Yul Edochie, Zack Orji and Benedict Johnson.