Take a fresh look at your lifestyle.

Supreme Court Chides Atiku, Obi’s Lawyers, Affirms Tinubu’s Election As President

0 334

 

The Supreme Court, while affirming the declaration of President Bola Ahmed Tinubu as the winner of the February 25 presidential election on Thursday, has condemned the conduct of the lawyers of the petitioners.

The court dismissed the appeals filed by former Vice President, Alhaji Atiku Abubakar, of the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) and Mr. Peter Obi of the Labour Party (LP), challenging Tinubu’s victory, as declared by the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) and affirmed by the Presidential Election Petition Tribunal (PEPT).

This is as the apex court accused lawyers of the petitioners of engaging in media trials and judgments, when Justice John Inyang Okoro was delivering the unanimous decision of the seven-man panel.

The court ruled that “On the whole, having resolved all the issues against the appellants, it is my view that there is no merit in this appeal and it is hereby dismissed.

“The judgment of the court below, delivered on the 6th of September 2003, affirming the election of second respondent as the duly elected president of the Federal Republic of Nigeria is thereby affirmed.

“I shall make no order as to costs,” the court said.

It had earlier dismissed the application by Abubakar, seeking to file fresh evidence against Tinubu, saying “the time to plead such evidence lapsed on September 17, when the lower court ceased to have jurisdiction over the matter.”

The court described as immutable, the 180 days fixed for hearing election petition, and added that it cannot be extended.

It also held that out of the seven issues distilled by the appellant for determination, none related or covered forgery, which he was seeking to bring in.

“The Constitution does not permit that, and this court has no jurisdiction, to grant the filing of fresh evidence that was not pleaded at the PEPC.”

Also dismissing the petition, which claimed that failure by the Independent Electoral Commission (INEC), to transmit results on the IREV, he affirmed that that did not affect the outcome of the election.

The appellants, it added, abandoned their duty to provide substantial evidence to prove noncompliance and that the failure of the electoral body to transmit election results electronically did not affect the presidential election.

“When IReV fails, it does not stop the collation of the results. It deprives people of viewing results.”

It said although the inability of INEC to electronically transmit the results will affect the trust of the electorates in the election, the “unavailability of IReV cannot be a ground for the election to be nullified.

“The failure did not affect the outcome of the election. The issue is resolved against the appellants,” the court stated.

It also dismissed the appeal of Obi challenging the nomination of Vice President Kassim Shettima to contest the election on grounds of double nomination, the court ruled that the matter had been determined by it earlier and was referred to by the lower court.

“There must be an end to litigation,” the court said, adding that the appeal lacks merit and accordingly dismissed.

On the appeal that Tinubu was not eligible to be declared the winner of the election, because he did not garner 25 percent of the votes in the Federal Capital Territory (FCT), it said the requirement did not matter in a Presidential Election.

“Are you saying if someone scores 25 percent votes in 30 states, but not in Abuja, he should not be president?

“Is that how you interpret the law? That is not the law. Supreme Court agrees with the Court of Appeal, the apex court said.

The court supported the criticism of lawyers of Atiku and Obi by judges of the Presidential Election Petition Court, which accused them of shoddy preparation.

while reacting to criticisms that greeted the comments by the judges, Okoro, while concluding the judgment, accused the lawyers of engaging in media trials and media judgments.

These actions, according to him had incited some followers of their clients to send threatening messages to judges and justices.

“I have read the judgment of the court below, and I’ve seen the context which those words were used.

“And it is my view that they were not meant to disparage the appellants or their counsel.

“As judges, we are trained to be template in our use of words and we shall continue to do so.

“Litigants are advised to trust the courts, whenever their matters are before it.

“It is very unbecoming these days, that while a matter is pending in court, litigants engage in press conferences, analysing the case, reaching conclusion.

“Based on this, some of their followers send threatening messages to judges and justices.

Matters in court are said to be sub judice, and as such, parties and probably their counsels should refrain from media trials and media judgments.

“I need not say more on this. A word is enough for the wise,” he concluded.

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.